The low scores indicate a high initial challenge, and not a long term pessimistic view.
With that said, if you can both adapt to the others style this is a relationship which will improve steadily over time, and eventually rival any other match.
You may both be intrigued by the others gifts in this area, but the overlap from a relationship standpoint is pretty much zero.
While you both may have an interest in the occult or metaphysical that's typically fairly irrelevant as the basis of a relationship.
You're an intellectual sign (air), and Pisces is an emotional one (water).
More to the point however, you're perhaps the least emotional of all zodiac signs, and Pisces is one of the most emotional.
It's important to note however that we're looking only at sun signs here.
There are many other planets which can have an equal or greater effect on someone's personality.
It can certainly work, and work well, but you both need to be prepared to meet in the middle.
Your Pisces is very likely to be willing to do this, if you are.
Makes sense, as ultimately everyone is of course unique.